Call Us Today! 1-877-236-0420

AI Can’t Replace Critical Thinking in Supply Chain Hiring

By Published On: November 19, 2026

Welcome back to the Supply Chain Careers Podcast. In this episode, we wrap up our three-part series on why supply chain hiring is so difficult. In the first two episodes, Rodney Apple, Chris Gaffney, and Mike Ogle explored the complexities of supply chain roles and why successful hiring starts with understanding the business need rather than simply matching candidates to job descriptions. In this final installment, the conversation turns to artificial intelligence, where it can improve recruiting, where it falls short, and why human critical thinking and specialized expertise remain essential. The group also shares practical takeaways for employers, talent professionals, and job seekers. These episodes are part of our Catalyst series, where we explore the trends, challenges, and opportunities shaping supply chain careers and talent management.

AI, Critical Thinking, and the Future of Supply Chain Hiring

If you’ve ever been tasked with filling a high level supply chain role, you can attest to the fact that it’s not as easy as checking the boxes on a job description. This 3 part podcast series explores all of the roadblocks to efficient supply chain hiring that seem more pronounced as technology further disrupts global supply chains.

In the third and final installment of the Supply Chain Careers Podcast’s three-part Catalyst discussion on supply chain hiring, Rodney Apple, Chris Gaffney, and Mike Ogle examine where AI can improve recruiting, where human expertise remains essential, and what employers and candidates can do to improve hiring outcomes.

Technology can help, but you still need people to do the heavy lifting.

Where AI Adds Value to Supply Chain Recruiting

Artificial Intelligence’s most valuable operating asset is speed. Reporting, analytics, data crunching, and pattern recognition are enhanced using AI. So, just as in supply chain operations itself, supply chain talent management has been positively impacted using AI. By quickly analyzing large volumes of information, AI can help uncover potential candidates that organizations could easily overlook.

Mike Ogle highlights several applications where AI can support the recruiting process, including identifying alternative job titles, mapping companies and industries, comparing resumes, and researching candidate backgrounds.

Rodney Apple shares examples of how SCM Talent Group uses AI to develop targeted sourcing strategies. For one search, AI helped identify companies using advanced planning systems such as Blue Yonder. For another, it helped map manufacturing facilities within commuting distance of a difficult-to-fill plant leadership position.

These applications can reduce the time required for preliminary research and expand the potential candidate pool.

However, AI’s effectiveness depends heavily on the quality of the information and the expertise of the person directing the research.

As Ogle explains, AI can accelerate the work, but it does not eliminate the need for a qualified recruiter who understands what information matters.

“AI can accelerate the work, but it doesn’t eliminate the person for sure.” –Mike Ogle

Why AI Still Struggles With Supply Chain Complexity

One of the biggest challenges in supply chain recruiting is understanding the scale, scope, and complexity of a candidate’s experience.

Consider two plant managers. One oversees a single-shift facility with 45 employees. Another manages a 24/7 manufacturing operation employing 500 people and hundreds of contractors.

Both may hold the same title, but the leadership requirements and operational challenges are dramatically different.

Chris Gaffney emphasizes that evaluating candidates requires understanding factors such as facility size, throughput, automation, organizational structure, and the complexity of the operating environment.

These distinctions are difficult to capture through job titles, resumes, and keyword searches alone.

AI can identify similarities between candidates, but it may struggle to determine whether experience gained in one environment translates effectively into another.

It can also have difficulty evaluating organizational maturity, leadership capabilities, and the trade-offs between different qualifications.

For employers, this creates a risk of overlooking strong candidates who lack an exact industry or title match but possess the capabilities needed to succeed.

AI can identify potential matches. Determining which candidates are truly qualified requires a deeper understanding of the business.

Critical Thinking Remains Essential to Successful Hiring

Throughout the three-part series, critical thinking emerges as one of the most important capabilities in supply chain recruiting.

Apple emphasizes that an effective recruiting process begins with understanding the broader business before narrowing the focus to a particular position.

That means examining the organization’s business model, operating environment, supply chain structure, strategic priorities, and the challenges a new hire will be expected to address.

Only then can employers and recruiters determine which qualifications are essential and which are preferences.

“You’ve got to understand what are those must-have skills, functional skills, technical skills. What would be nice to have.” – Rodney Apple

This distinction becomes particularly important when evaluating candidates from adjacent industries or with unconventional career paths.

A candidate may lack one preferred qualification while bringing extensive experience solving similar operational challenges. Recognizing that potential requires understanding transferable skills and the ability to evaluate competing strengths.

The same principle applies to compensation. Market research and candidate feedback may reveal that an employer’s original salary expectations do not align with the talent available.

Experienced recruiters must be able to recognize these disconnects, challenge assumptions, and help employers make informed decisions.

Rather than simply executing a search against an existing job description, specialized recruiters serve as advisors who help employers refine their hiring strategy.

Better Hiring Requires Stronger Business Partnerships

Successful recruiting also depends on the relationship between hiring managers, human resources, and talent acquisition professionals.

Gaffney emphasizes that HR and recruiting teams are most effective when they understand the business and maintain ongoing relationships with its leaders.

That familiarity allows them to anticipate talent needs, challenge outdated job descriptions, and provide meaningful guidance when hiring expectations do not reflect operational realities.

“You need to at least hire for the job you actually believe someone’s going to be doing.” –Chris Gaffney

Apple recalls an experience early in his career at The Home Depot, when a senior supply chain executive invited him to work directly alongside the business leadership team.

Participating in those conversations provided greater visibility into the organization’s strategy, challenges, and priorities.

The experience reinforced an important lesson: recruiters who understand the business are better equipped to identify the talent needed to move it forward.

This partnership also supports a more disciplined hiring process.

Employers should define success before launching a search, establish clear priorities, evaluate market feedback, and avoid unnecessary delays.

Gaffney also cautions against placing too much emphasis on technical qualifications while overlooking leadership and interpersonal skills. The ability to lead through uncertainty, manage change, and build effective teams often determines whether a technically qualified candidate succeeds.

What Supply Chain Professionals Can Do to Stand Out

The discussion also offers important guidance for supply chain professionals navigating an increasingly AI-influenced hiring market.

Job titles alone rarely communicate the full extent of someone’s experience. Candidates need to make the scale, scope, and complexity of their accomplishments easier for employers and recruiters to understand.

Ogle encourages professionals to quantify their responsibilities and results. That includes the size of teams managed, budgets controlled, facilities operated, operational improvements delivered, and business outcomes achieved.

“You can’t just assume that your title ends up explaining what you do and what you want to do.” – Mike Ogle

Candidates should also explain their individual contributions to major initiatives rather than simply listing projects in which they participated.

Gaffney highlights the importance of demonstrating accountability, adaptability, and a willingness to take on increasingly challenging responsibilities.

These experiences help establish a record of leadership and provide meaningful examples that support the claims made on a resume.

AI can help candidates organize and refine their resumes or LinkedIn profiles, but it should not replace their own understanding of their accomplishments.

As Apple notes, candidates should make their experience understandable to recruiters and HR professionals who may not have deep supply chain expertise.

The objective is not simply to include the right keywords. It is to communicate why a candidate’s experience matters.

The Future of Supply Chain Hiring Requires Both Technology and Expertise

Across this three-part Catalyst discussion, several consistent themes emerge:

  • Supply chain hiring is difficult because the discipline encompasses a wide range of functions, operating models, and business environments. Job titles and traditional job descriptions rarely capture that complexity.
  • Successful hiring begins with clearly defined business objectives, realistic expectations, and an understanding of the capabilities required to achieve specific outcomes.
  • AI offers opportunities to improve research, sourcing, and recruiting efficiency. However, technology alone cannot replace the business knowledge, critical thinking, and judgment necessary to evaluate complex supply chain talent.

The responsibilities of employers, recruiters, and supply chain professionals differ, but their objectives are closely aligned. For employers, the priority is defining the business need, maintaining flexibility, and collaborating with knowledgeable talent professionals. For recruiters, success requires becoming trusted business advisors rather than simply matching resumes to job descriptions. And for supply chain professionals, the challenge is effectively communicating the scope, complexity, and measurable impact of their experience.

Checking the boxes on a job description might yield results, but not necessarily the right ones. The perfect candidate may not exist, but the right candidate for your organization does. Combining AI with human expertise can help identify that talent more efficiently, provided the search remains grounded in clearly defined business objectives.

Listen to the third and final installment of the Supply Chain Careers Podcast’s Catalyst series on the complexities of supply chain hiring, featuring Rodney Apple, Chris Gaffney, and Mike Ogle.

Chris Gaffney:

So the, the next topic that we’re gonna dig into is how do you actually get the information that really matters when you’re trying to discern whether a candidate really packs the gear or frankly, you know, um, if, if you’re the candidate trying to understand what you’re walking into on the role. Um, and the trick is, you know, [00:01:00] today we live in the world of using AI and, you know, using, you know, what’s on LinkedIn to look at a candidate to say, you know, what have they really done?

And that, that doesn’t always get us there, right? And, and particularly if we’re talking about site leadership, multi-site leadership, um, you know, it’s important for you to understand if they ran a facility that’s a one-shift facility with forty-five people versus a twenty-four/seven plant that employs five hundred people and five hundred contractors.

Those are so different. Product mix is different. I mean, we’ve had, you know, super big Coke plants that all they did was– were run cans, which were very easy to run. So even then the volume was high, and the throughput could be high, but the complexity wasn’t very high. So there’s a lot of that, you know, that we’re gonna contend that you need to understand size, headcount, throughput, complexity.

Is it twenty four/seven? What is [00:02:00] the operating model? What’s the literal environment, um, in that plant? Um, where are they from an automation standpoint? You know, work structure, right? And if you’re, if you’re running a facility, are all your support resources decentralized, so you’re really on your own physically, or do you have a bunch of people on site that you could spread the load with?

Um, you know, is, is this business stuck in the mud, or have they gone through lots of transformation? And then that, you know, really gets down to w- how difficult is this role? Is this person a caretaker or are they, you know, a battlefield commander having to lead from the front every day? So I think the trick is where do you get this information, right?

So, um, I think that’s kinda what we wanna dive in– into is kind of our tricks of the trade in terms of how you do it. So, so Mike, AI has jumped in and, and, you know, it helps in some places, but, but it doesn’t help. So what, what’s your– what are your thoughts, you know, from [00:03:00] that standpoint?

Mike Ogle: Well, I’d say number one, it’s a really fantastic tool for being able to comb through a wide range of information, cast a really wide net, uh, bring in a lot of things.

But one of the things that we really have to be able to understand is it, it really can’t reliably interpret information that either, uh, doesn’t exist in a, in a good form, but, uh, maybe a person knows how to chase it down, or if you’re not asking for it in the right way, you know, through the best kinds of prompts or whether it’s agents that you’ve constantly got out there that you set up to, to go look at resources that a person knows what they’re looking for.

So I think you’re going to constantly have to tune those kinds of things as opposed to, like, a set it and forget it. Uh, ’cause it also keeps changing as time goes by. And where AI can really have that kind of significant value and do the [00:04:00] things that are going to help us out, I think one of them is even getting started in the beginning, the planning process.

You know, if you can just sit there as a, as a person, as a recruiter or somebody as a, as a supply chain, uh, director, VP looking for somebody to go through the process of figuring out, “Well, here’s, here’s the things I’m looking for.” And, and you can come up with rough bullet lists and qualifications, things that you think matter, and having it try to spit something out that gives you a really clear, uh, kind of elevator speech back to yourself or to your team and helping lay out the research process.

If, if this is the kind of person I’m looking for, what are the things I should do? And it can give you a lot of great ideas. It’s not gonna be perfect. You can’t follow it like a script. But it’s going to do some really good things for you in helping you go through your thinking process in the beginning.[00:05:00]

But one of the things it doesn’t really– Uh, sorry, another thing that it can do well is identifying a variety of all kinds of adjacent titles. So a title, as we’ve talked about before in this series, uh, can really be misleading, especially depending on those other characteristics that Chris was just talking about that we need to know.

So you wanna be able to get the job duties and responsibilities and be able to find out what some of those adjacent titles might be. It also does a great job at company and industry mapping. Are there connections between things that you didn’t think about of other companies or even internally within companies of how you can do the mapping of activities, people, plants, involvement with other, other kinds of companies?

You know, discovering candidates, that’s one that people have been using a lot just to try to do some of the matchmaking process. But as we’ve talked about and will continue to talk about, it’s difficult, [00:06:00] but it can help with parts of the discovery process. And finding patterns and connections, I mean, that’s one of the places it excels, particularly when you have a focused set of criteria that you’re pretty confident in.

And then another one is just resume comparison. Can you find some keywords? Yes, that’s important, but also for experience and accomplishments and ways that you– if, if you’ve got a human helping AI, it can be a great assistant for you. But where it struggles is trying to assess the complexity of a supply chain operation.

You know, Chris talked about a variety of factors that we need to take a look at, but can it really understand complexity? Can it really understand or assess the transferable skills and experiences when somebody has some other kind of experience? How does that translate into another world or industry?

And then assessing which experience actually matters to a job. These are the kinds of things that people can kinda do [00:07:00] naturally, but we haven’t really taught or trained AI to be able to get that good at it And knowing when an industry requirement should be flexed or not. Hey, does this really matter?

Can you put a scoring system on it? It’s difficult for AI to be able to make that happen. And organizational maturity. If somebody’s moving from one spot to another, does it really understand what that means? And I’d say probably the last one there would be identifying some of the legitimate trade-offs between different factors that when it reads a resume, can it really say, “Hey, this is a little bit of an area that’s lacking, but they’re really strong in these three others, so I should put them at, uh, you know, a little h- bit higher on the list.”

I think people do that more naturally than AI can do it. So AI can accelerate the work, but it doesn’t eliminate the person for sure. It just helps that person, a really qualified recruiter or, or assessor [00:08:00] of skills, it can help them do a better job

Chris Gaffney: Hey, Rodney, I, I’m curious what’s that balance that’s working for, for you and your team?

Um, you know, I, I agree with Mike. AI is really a powerful research tool. I mean, it’s much better than a Google search. It’s much better than fishing around on LinkedIn. Um, but I do think it… There’s a bit of art and science there, right? If I’m, if I’m looking at a candidate, you know, I may wanna narrow into what, where is the site that they said they worked at, and then I can do some research.

I can ha- have it look at Google, Google Maps. What’s the physical footprint of the site? What’s the level of activity? Is it hundreds of dock doors? You know, what’s going on there? Um, have it crowdsource what’s been said by current and past employees, truck drivers going in and out of… To get some sense of it.

I mean, even local news media, have they been investing a lot in that site? So, like, you could [00:09:00] get some of that background in there. But to Mike’s point, there’s still a lot of limitations. So I, I’m curious what’s working well for you and your team, and where is it still old-fashioned shoe leather legwork, you know, by, you know, people talking to other people.

Yeah, that’s a great question. I’m glad you asked, uh, Chris. Um, yeah, on the research side, you know, when you think about putting together a sourcing strategy, I, I think it does a great job there. Um, now whether, you know, it’s a… we’re, we’re looking for some analog companies, you know, who are the direct competitors, um, it, it does a good job with, with listing out, you know, companies.

And if you prompt it correctly, if you, if you give it the right information and, you know, the AI platform, whichever one you’re using. We use ChatGPT quite a bit. You can, you can get it to do some pretty impressive things. I’ve had it generate spreadsheets, uh, target list of companies. I put in the key attributes, “Hey, I’m, I’m looking for companies that have advanced planning, [00:10:00] uh, that have S&OP, uh, that may have im- that have, that are Blue Yonder users.”

I mean, those are some real examples of, of criteria that we’ve put into the model, and it’ll spit out not just a list, but I’ve got it to a place where it can s- it can crank out spreadsheets, and in the various columns it’ll list out those attributes. Yeah, these are Blue Yonder users or, um, they moved to advanced planning.

Um, that, that’s one example. Another is we’ve got a, a, a confidential plant manager. It’s in, it’s in a remote area of, of Arkansas. And, and, uh, I basically, uh, to, to what you just mentioned earlier, Chris, had it, had it go out and, and, and pull, um, uh, the various- Plants, uh, the names of the plants in the area.

And I, and I said, “Bring back any information you can, uh, that speaks to the types of products, the size, the number of employees.” And it was able to produce a pretty robust list, uh, that were in commuting proximity. [00:11:00] Um, so that was the first cut. And then I had to, you know, produce, like, going out into surrounding suburbs, uh, even over towards Memphis.

Not quite a commute, um, but not too far away and, and, and list out, you know, plants in that area. Um, then you take that and you can just plug it into, you know, LinkedIn, LinkedIn Recruiter and, and pretty easily identify the plant managers. Although, as we talked about earlier, they may not be called plant managers.

That’s where that critical thinking, uh, comes into play. You’ve really ought to- gotta understand, you know, what are the potential titles. I’ve seen vice presidents, I’ve seen plant managers, and so forth. So it does a good job with, uh, what I would call, you know, broad sourcing, uh, strategy, and it can even pull in some insights from various sources that could help you determine if it’s a really good target, um, or not.

So that’s, that’s where we use it on the, on the, on the sourcing side. Uh, we’ve also… Like speaking of Blue- Blue Yonder, we had a, a VP of planning, and they wanted somebody with that background to include AI and, [00:12:00] uh, we were able to prompt it to go out and look, uh, through, like, Blue Yonder’s website. Looking at case studies, identifying people that had spoken at conferences about, uh, how they’ve deployed some of the latest versions and tools coming out of Blue Yonder.

So I thought that was pretty impressive that it could scour, you know, the internet, many different sources. I had it, uh, go after the supply chain trade associations that we’re all familiar with. And, and it came back with a pretty good list of, of potential candidates too. So, so critical thinking, and, and that’s kind of our next topic.

That’s, that’s where it can really separate, um, and add some, some value that can accelerate, you know, not just the research, but target list and, and then even getting into mapping out candidates within those companies. Obviously, you know, summarizing notes and putting together executive summaries for clients, uh, scorecards, things like that.

It’s, it’s, it’s pretty powerful. Um, uh- Where, where it doesn’t, um, do so well, uh, is, is [00:13:00] really kind of what we’ve been talking about is just, is, uh, yeah, and this, this probably applies, you know, going into LinkedIn Recruiter. I’ll talk about that, too, because they have AI tools embedded. We’re actually going through our renewal right now with our rep, our LinkedIn rep, and they’ve built a brand-new platform from, you know, the ground up that’s, that’s AI and, and we did some demos with it and I gave it a couple of these tricky searches that are very gray.

A lot of ambiguity. They’re, they’re not easy to figure out and, um, it struggled with coming out with candidates, and I, and I had a feeling it would. And so we deci- we declined to upgrade to, to the latest package. We just didn’t think it would do so well in this world of supply chain. It probably does very, very well when you think about more black and white roles.

Could be sales, could be marketing, could be accounting, things that don’t have as much complexity and grayness. Um, so, so that’s– wanted to add that in because it is a, it is an interesting time. Um, but I don’t think it’s quite ready for, [00:14:00] uh, for our needs, um, uh, in, in supply chain because of all the factors that we’ve rattled off here, uh, across the last two series.

Chris Gaffney: Yeah. I mean, I’ll add one more thing from my vantage point of what we’re seeing in the research and the work we’re doing with industry at Georgia Tech. You know, our audience here are either hiring managers or candidates and, you know, in both cases, as you said, it, it’s still not really ready for prime time.

But I think where it works well, it really is still you the hiring manager or you the candidate doing the real work and letting AI augment you, right? It’s not, “Go find me great candidates.” That’s not gonna work any time in the future, right? You’ve got to do all the subtleties to guide AI to where, um, it can give you some constructive help.

But the other thing I would say is you got to keep an eye on it because the six-month learning [00:15:00] curve or the six-month capability curve is pretty steep. So I think it’s not a live with it or live without it. It’s put it in the right place and keep an eye. There may be things that it can’t do effectively today but it might be able to do very effectively three months down the road.

Mike Ogle: Yeah. And with the money- Exactly … that’s being pumped into th- that world right now, uh, there’s a massive motivation to be as, as fast as you can possibly be. So it’s almost a quarterly curve instead of the six month.

Chris Gaffney: Yep. Agree, Mike.

Yeah, and it kind of le- it segues right into our, our next topic that what, what, what, what’s required.

Um, and, and I’m 25 plus years in, in recruiting in the supply chain space is, you know, it is critical thinking. When we look for, uh, recruiters on our team, you know, we are looking for those that, that can work with the gray. You know? And, um, they, they can ask good questions and, and distill through all this complexity and, [00:16:00] and get down to, you know, what, what is the core requirements, and factor in all these nuances that we’ve talked about.

Because, um, it, it’s, it’s not easy, and I find myself serving as an advisor and as a coach, uh, oftentimes to, to clients when they start describing, um, a role that’s really maybe two roles put into one, or they’re, they, they go down this path of way too many things on their wish list. Um, you know, it’s, it’s, it’s our job to, to kind of bring them back down to, to reality, and that’s where we get into the trade-off discussions and things like that.

But, you know, to be successful in this field, you know, you… And this is where we start every single search when we kick it off. It’s I go high level. I have to understand your business. I have to understand the bus- business model. Uh, how do you go to market? What are your channels? You know, do you insource, do you outsource, you know, production or, or distribution or both?

You know, we, we’ve got to understand, um, the structure of the broader business and, you know, where are the… You know, [00:17:00] do you have various business units? Um, you know, divisions. Do they… D- is, is there some kind of synergies? Is there a center of excellence? Uh, shared services. Uh, um, you know, all of that comes into play.

Do you have your own fleet? We’ve got to ask all these questions, kind of the things we’ve talked about at the beginning of, of the series. Um, what’s the operating environment? Um, if it’s a manufacturing, it’s going to be different than retail. It’s going to be slightly different than wholesale distribution.

Um, and then you get into a s- a myriad of, of, of types of businesses when you get into like the logistics and supply chain service providers, 3PLs, 4PLs, et cetera. Um, and then, you know, understanding what needs to change. You know, what are the objectives, deliverables? What do you want this person to solve for in the first year or two?

Um, and, and then really crystallizing that. Let’s, let’s force rank those. What’s, what’s, what keeps you up at night? What’s number one? What’s number two? What’s number three? These are things that AI is just not going to be able to filter through, at least not right now. Um, knowing what the capabilities, what [00:18:00] matters the most.

Um, you’ve got to, you’ve got to factor in if it’s a broad supply chain role, you know, not everyone is going to have the exact same profile. That doesn’t mean they can’t do the job, but you’ve, you’ve got to understand what are those must-have skills, functional skills, technical skills. Uh, what would be nice to have.

Um, also being able to recognize, you know, from, from one function to another, one industry, uh, to another. We know what’s, what’s transferable, what’s not transferable. You’ve got to be able to look beyond titles. That’s super important as we’ve talked about. Plant managers, distribution center managers, you know, they, they could have at least ten to fifteen titles each, maybe more.

Um, so you’ve got to be able to, to do that critical thinking, that research and understand if you’re looking for a DC manager or, or even that layer below, um, inbound, outbound, what, what does… I’m looking in retail, what does Amazon call them versus Walmart versus Target? Uh, you will find that it, it is drastically different.

They do not use the exact same titles. Uh, I, I kind of wish they did because it would be nice to have some [00:19:00] standardization, uh, but they don’t and, and they probably never will. And that just makes it more complex. Um, and it goes back to that critical thinking skills. We talked about the trade-offs. You know, we talked about, um, you know- Getting too narrow, um, when it comes to target companies.

I, I need somebody out of these five or 10 companies. Well, there’s only gonna be a finite number of people that have held those titles in those companies, so you’ve gotta keep an open mind, um, for success. And then, and then compensation. Um, companies come to us all the time, “Yeah, we just ran this through our, our compensation partner and did a study, and so this is the range.”

And, and then, uh, oftentimes I find myself challenging that range. That’s, that’s not reality today, and here’s why. Uh, so asking good questions, uh, learning about the broader business, you know, getting into the supply chain organization, and then eventually you get down into that role. That’s kinda how we, we start.

Broader business, get down into the organization, wherever that role [00:20:00] sits. How does it connect the dots, you know, across the different supply chain internally, externally? And then you start focusing on that person’s department as well as the role. A lot of recruiters make the mistake, they just, “Give me a job description, give me a salary range.

I’m off to the races.” And, uh, if, if, if, if, if, if you’re an employer and, and your recruiter’s or search partner’s not asking these, these questions, they’re, they’re gonna struggle, so.

Mike Ogle: If it was- Chris, what do you, what- If it was standardized- Go ahead, Mike. Oh, go ahead. I’m sorry.

No, you’re fine.

Chris Gaffney: No, go a- go ahead, Mike.

Mike Ogle: I was just gonna say, if it was standardized and it wasn’t complex, then, uh, it’s not really appropriate for a skilled recruiter.

Yeah. Yeah, I, I think that’s a, that’s a great point. It really, and it really sums up what we’re talking about here today, is, uh, there’s just a lot of complexity out there. And if there was more standardization, you know, we’ve got the SCORE model.

You do see standardization on a lot of things when it comes to process. [00:21:00] Um, but, uh, when it comes to the nuances in the business and the jargon and the acronyms, it’s all over the board. Just thinking about even continuous improvement, um, you know, you’ve got the, uh, various versions of that, those, those, those models.

Um, every company might call it something different even though at the heart of it, it’s the same thing, right? Yeah, I was gonna ask- I mean,

Chris Gaffney: I-

Chris- Go

Chris Gaffney: ahead. Go ahead, Brian.

Yeah, yeah. I was gonna say, you know, obviously you’ve been a, an executive, um, uh, in a few different companies. Coca-Cola is where you spent most of your career.

But, um, you know, what have, what have you seen? I know I supported you when I was at Coke there for a while, um, leading their recruitment and supply chain. But, you know, what, what do you feel is important when you factor all these things in that we’ve been talking about?

Chris Gaffney: Yeah, it’s an excellent question. I, I literally talked to somebody today, or la- last night, and they had somebody exit their organization.

And it’ll ultimately be, the, the debate where, you know, were they the right [00:22:00] candidate or were they not in the right setting? How much of it was the candidate? How much was the manager? Getting the right person in the role is absolutely a balance of, of art and science. Um, I think, you know, as I worked over the years, um- You’ve gotta do the legwork if you’re the hiring manager to portray the role correctly.

Otherwise, your, your talent people, they’re, they’re looking for the wrong thing, right? And, a- and I’m always concerned when someone’s in a hurry. You know, back to topics we’ve had before. It’s like, “Oh, here’s the existing job description. Just go hunt this down.” It’s almost like every single time, even if there requires some HR involvement, if you’re adjusting the job description for it to be revisited, y- you need to at least hire for the job you actually believe someone’s going to be doing.

So I, I think as, as the hiring manager, that’s the most important thing. I also think it’s not… Y- you don’t just hand that off to the recruiter. [00:23:00] You have a discussion with them, right? This is the environment we’re in. This is the, you know, the prior person left under these circumstances, so that’s relevant or not to, to the, the hiring situation.

This is the peer group. All these other things. So at least back to the critical thinking people, you’re giving whoever’s doing the recruiting… And if you have to do some of it yourself, I’d rather you be thoughtful about this. What’s the context, right? So here’s the job, and here’s the environment. I think that, that gives you the first thing, ’cause you could talk to candidates about it so they know what they’re getting into.

And then you can do a better job of s- getting a sense through quantitative, qualitative referencing, whatever. What’s the likelihood that this person will be successful there? ‘Cause that’s really the question. Um, and then I think it’s, it’s process, right? Um, you know, back and forth, Rodney, we would go. And unfortunately at Coke, if you post a job, you get 6,000 applicants.

So you’ve gotta do a bit of the, you know, needle in a haystack there and hope you get the best of the best [00:24:00] with that first cursory look, which is really hard now with AI. Um, but if you get that decent cut, then you do some calibration. And if the recruiter says, “Hey, I think these people are a fit,” you’re like, “No, I think you were missing what I said.

So I wanna tweak what we were saying,” and let them go back in and say, “Okay, now that you’ve adjusted it, here are the people I think we ought to take a first crack at.” And, and you know as well as I do today, y- you’ve gotta be efficient at that. You know, you phone screen. Whatever you’re doing to get a better shot at saying, “I think these people are worth us investing some time in.”

And then it’s… It is still, in my view, mostly old-fashioned. I know some companies do testing and that type of thing. And in very rare circumstances in senior roles, we’d put somebody through a battery of tests once we thought they were the candidate. But I think it’s exposing to multiple people. And I think that’s also rigor, right?

I mean, there were times at Coke we were in a hurry. We’d do one panel of interviews with three people. We’d make an offer the next day. And there’s some [00:25:00] risk associated with that, right? I know, I know other people who are like, “Well, gosh, I went through 14 interviews. This company, they wore me out.” But they might be better off if they handle that well because they’re, they’re bringing multiple voices in to evaluate.

And back to their critical thinking, they get different perspectives. So There’s no AI in a lot of what I’ve just said. That’s, that, that’s still thoughtful business process because beyond the environment, beyond the job, you still have to say, “Fit. Is this person going to be successful in our organization based on their, their motivational fit, our culture,” all that other kind of stuff.

So I think that, that it’s still hard work, Rodney, and that’s why, you know, you and your team are in business, you know?

Yeah, it’s funny, Chris. Uh, I mean, those are great points you brought up, of course. But, uh, you know, as I take calls from, from various companies looking for supply chain talent, I often hear, you know, “Well, we- we’ve, you know, we’ve been using this recruiter for years across areas of our business, and they usually [00:26:00] do a good job.

But man, they are just missing the mark over here in supply chain.” And I, I hear it so often, and it, and it really speaks to the whole, you know, three-part series that we have here. You know, this, this, this– there’s just so much ambiguity, and there’s so much complexity and, um, you know, we talked about that critical thinking and, you know, having seen so many things over these twenty-five plus years, you know, we’re– you know, we, we can speed up that process of cutting through the layers of ambiguity and getting right down, you know, to distilling it to, to what is the core of this role, what is the essence, and where do we go find these people?

Plus, uh, how do we identify them? How do we market the role? Um, how do we vet and assess the candidates properly too? Like, all of those things come together, uh, uh, and that’s what yields a successful hire. But let’s, let’s get into some takeaways because that’s– we’re gonna wrap up on, you know, we- we’ve, we’ve– we’re– we’ve, we’ve heard about the complexity, the ambiguity.

We’ve, we’ve, uh, we’ve kind of beat that to death here in the first, uh, uh, two parts of this [00:27:00] three-part series. So what’s important for, you know, employers, uh, for hiring leaders? What’s important for the, the HR folks that support, uh, operations and supply chain? And then, um, what is some advice for, for the supply chain professionals, the practitioners?

How can they leverage this information for their benefit? So I’ll, I’ll kick it off with employers, and this will be a little bit repetitive, but, you know, a lot of what we’ve discussed today, it comes back to taking proper time up front before you go to market to try to fill the position. Um, we’ve got to a place where if we can’t have access to the hiring manager Or anyone else that’s involved with that decision-making with the hiring process, we will not take the search assignment.

Too many times, uh, HR has stepped in, “Oh, my, my, my C- COO or head of supply chain is too busy. You could just talk to me, and if I can’t answer the questions, I’ll go back to that person and get you the answers.” And like, nah, that, that [00:28:00] doesn’t work. Um, and, and usually within the first two or three minutes, I’ll know if that HR person knows their stuff or not.

And, and oftentimes, uh, they don’t, and, and then sometimes they surprise me and they do. Uh, but it, it kinda goes back to, um, creating the time and space, uh, to, to go through and dig through the questions and make sure that you are fully aligned, you’re joined at the hip with, with what that profile looks like, that candidate profile, the trade-offs, and all the other things that we’ve talked about.

So, um, start out with the business need. Um, don’t just, you know, crank out that old job description. Um, I know in, when I worked in, uh, let’s just say Fortune 500, they would recycle a lot of the same job descriptions. Uh, they all looked the same from department to department, and I would have to have the hiring manager, “Hey, I need you to crank something out here in that position overview.”

And that was the only thing that might be different on the job description. So you just can’t rely on the job descriptions. I’ve gotten to a place [00:29:00] where, uh, they’re important. I, I’m gonna look at them. Uh, rarely are they accurate. Like, I’ll get through with the intake, and I’ll look at the job description.

I’m like, “These two things are different,” and there’s a lot of variance and, and sometimes we’ll, we find ourselves updating the job description on the employer’s or the client’s behalf just to get it, you know, accurate, um, with what we were told, um, to look for. So start out with that business need. Define what success is gonna look like.

Um, if I fly into the future, you know, another year out or two years out and, um, look at what’s been accomplishment, what’s been accomplished during that timeframe for this role, um, you know, you need to understand what those three to five objectives are, and ideally, you can force rank those. Uh, I love it when we take a search and, and I ask that question, the client’s like, “Yeah, absolutely.

Number one, they need to be able to do X. Number two, they need to do Y. Number three, Z.” It just, it just tells me they’ve done their homework, and they, they, they know exactly what they’re looking for. Um, [00:30:00] in, in contrast, though, when, when a cl- when, when a hiring manager can’t tell me, “Well, they need to get along with the team,” and I’m like, “Uh, we’ve got work to do here.”

And, and, and oftentimes, you know, we kick that search off, and we regret taking it on because they, they get through the middle of the process, and they change their mind. So- So if you’re, if you’re not sure what you need and what you want, you, you wanna spend more time reflecting on that because, uh, you know, um, you’re gonna waste time, and, and you’re gonna probably not just waste time, but you’re gonna frustrate a l- a lot of people in the process.

Candidates, candidates talk, uh, put people through the wringers, and then you decide, “Hey, I… You know, we’re gonna put the role on hold,” or, or, “We’re gonna switch gears and pivot. We actually need this, uh, instead of that.” So, uh, key message here, do all that work up front. Really understand what the functional expertise, what’s critical for the role.

You know, the leadership capabilities, especially as you go up the ladder, those become even more important, um, especially if you’re looking for that change agent, [00:31:00] um, change the culture, you know, uh, accomplish a, a lot of objectives in a short timeframe. You see that a lot in private equity, uh, uh, owned companies.

Um, so know those true must-haves from the preferences. You know, understand if I can’t get that, what are the trade-offs? Uh, don’t automatically clone the person that you’re trying to replace. Um, and don’t focus on listing out A to Z, you know, this laundry list of skills. I call it skills-infested job descriptions.

Please avoid that because you’re gonna start describing, uh, a role that or a person that just does not exist in the marketplace. Um, be open-minded. Uh- Critical to be open-minded. You can’t be stubborn, you can’t be closed-minded. Um, uh, it’s not gonna get you anywhere. Uh, l- look for something if you can’t get exact, you know, industry match, my direct competitors.

You’ve gotta know, uh, and you want [00:32:00] your search partners or recruiters to know exactly where I can go. The A list is right here. If you can’t… If you go down that list and you can’t get people that are holding these jobs or they’ve held those jobs in the past, then I want you to go right over here into this adjacent industry segment.

After that, I want you to go over here. It does not mean we are sacrificing quality. Uh, it just means we, we are gonna be fishing in comparable ponds, um, you know, for similar talent where you find that level of complexity or they’ve solved some similar business challenges. Uh, you know, again, determine what that expertise is that can be developed.

Um, this person has three out of the five things we’re looking for. They’ve got some exposure to these other two. I think we can develop that within a reasonable, uh, timeframe. And then you’ve gotta understand too, like what, you know, uh, don’t just focus on the role, um, and, and the business outcomes you’re trying, you’re trying to solve for.

You’ve gotta [00:33:00] understand the full, uh, scope of your organization, whether it’s at the plan or a site, distribution center, whether it’s a corporate within a department. Um, do we have people on this team? Like, if I hire the leader, um, a- and, and they don’t have all the skills we need, where else in the team can we go to close these gaps?

Um, sometimes you might need to go outside and think about contractors, interim or fractional talent. Uh, we get a lot of requests for those, especially these days, um, for people that can, can, can fill a, a specific gap, uh, on an existing team. Uh, make sure early and often you’re, you’re pressure testing compensation.

Uh, you’ve gotta do that, you know, and, and look at what the candidates… Make sure your recruiters are, are, are getting their compensation targets. Uh, over time you can, you can assess that data and, and look at it against your compensation, uh, based on the profiles of the candidates. Some might be more experienced and more qualified than others, but it gives you a [00:34:00] good pulse on, am I in the ballpark or do we have more homework to do to try to get our compensation range where it needs to be, you know, to make it attractive for the, for those best in class candidates?

Um, understand too the cost of what, what is it costing to the organization? And it might not be financial. It could be burning out others on the team that are, that are, that are carrying these additional responsibilities because the role has been open for so long. What’s the cost of leaving that job open?

Um, make sure you, you, you factor in, um- Uh, the, the market research. A-a-and what I mean by that is, you know, calibrate early and often. Uh, we, we tell our clients, um, especially if it’s like a newly created role, um, you, you, you should engage early and often with, uh, candidates that we’re presenting. Um, you know, ca- it, it just gives you a good chance to speak to people.

You might change your mind a little bit and [00:35:00] realize, oh, okay, I don’t really need this, or I absolutely need that. Um, so, so having those conversations with candidates, um, especially if it’s a role that you’re making some changes to or if it’s a newly created role, that’s gonna give you a lot of information, a lot of intel, um, to help you either confirm that what I think is right is, is, is accurate, or do we have more work to do, um, to fine-tune the role, the skills, experience that we’re looking for.

Um, and Chris, you touched on this earlier, you know, somebody going through multiple rounds, you know, 14 different interviews. Um, you, you, you, you can’t do that these days. Uh, demand is still very high, especially for these transformational supply chain leaders. So have a good process. Make sure you’ve got that executive sponsor that is pushing the team to move quickly.

That’s, that’s important, especially for big roles, um, you know, executive roles. You, you’ve, you, you just can’t, you can’t leave these roles open for too long, and you [00:36:00] cannot move them through too many rounds of interviews. Um, you’re gonna lose the candidate. The person’s gonna get frustrated, and they’re gonna move on to something else

Chris Gaffney: Yeah, I mean, I, I would emphasize a couple of points, Rodney.

Um, if you’re disorganized in your process, you’re not aligned, you know, internally, um, you know, with all the right folks in terms of this is what we’re after, um, everything communicates, right? The candidate will be like, “What’s going on with these people?” And again, back to your point, you know, if you want the best candidates and they’re not treated well in the process, those are the people who don’t take your offer or pull from the process.

So I think that’s the first thing. Um, we’ve talked about it a lot, and yes, in many cases the supply chain is becoming more technical. Um, but most of your greatest successes and failures in these leadership roles are on the house and the soft skills. Um, [00:37:00] it’s not a hundred zero, but if you’re going eighty/twenty on the technicals, do they, do they, you know, are they Johnny Bravo?

Do they fit the suit? And you underestimate or under assess how well they lead, how they handle stress, all those other soft skills, you know, how they lead through challenging times and changing times. The technical side isn’t gonna win the day. So I, I think, you know, to me, those, those things matter a lot.

Um, again, if you’re after, if you’re after the best, best candidates. And I do think you have to make it a priority, right? If, if, if the candidates are constantly like, “What’s going on?” Um, a-again, you’re gonna have your bad candidates or your less attractive candidates stick with you because they’re… they need something.

But your best candidates are like, “This is not a serious outfit,” right? So I, I just– you, you mentioned a number of those points, but I would just put a fine point on that. [00:38:00]

Absolutely. No, you’re… those are great adds, Chris Yeah, and you know, it’s obviously you’ve worked as a, as a supply chain executive for, for decades, and you, you’ve worked with a lot of different HR partners, a lot of recruiters, including myself.

Um, what are some advice that we should talk about for those that, that support the supply chain function that are working in those, uh, you know, HR and talent acquisition capacities?

Chris Gaffney: Well, I mean, it goes without saying, um, is ideally you have an ongoing relationship with those businesspeople, right? You’re, you’re not just in and out with them.

Um, you’re close enough to what’s going on, A, you have a forward sense that they may have needs, but you’re also close enough to them to know what’s going on i- in the business and, you know, you get a sense of who are the people who should be involved in these panels and, you know, where is this jo- job from a, you know, from a, [00:39:00] um, you know, from a prioritization standpoint.

So I think being close… I mean, I always wanted to say be a business partner, right? I think that’s the number one thing I would say. You win in all aspects if you’re doing that, right? They trust you. They know you. You know them. So when you get into a more challenging part of the process and you’re trying to advocate for potentially, you know, a candidate who might be a, a bit unconventional for them, you got a better chance of being, of having some influence there.

So that’s probably kind of job one. Um, I think what’s implicit with that is if you’re closer to the business, you know what’s going on with their strategy. You have enough, um, context to be able to say, “Guys, I, I think what I’m hearing from you is not fully reflected on this job description, what I’m seeing from the team.”

So you’re, you come from a place of credibility if you want to push back a little bit, um, with, with those folks that are, that are there. So I think that leads to so many other things, [00:40:00] um, because in many cases, you’re the one who’s going to have to enforce discipline on them. You’re the one who’s going to ask them to, you know, focus on this a little more than they would like to.

You know, it’s kind of y- you know, that old, old saying, measure twice, cut once, right? You know, you’re the person who’s going to be the advocate for the best process to get them the final outcome, whereas in the front end, they’re going to be the one whose tendency is, “Let’s just go get this done, Rodney.

Let’s get back to running the business.” So I think- You know, I think the relationship enables so many of these other things where you’re gonna be the one who’s gonna wanna, you know, ask them to do the things that they don’t do all the time. I mean, that’s, that’s part of what your positioning is, is guys, you run this business all the time.

I source talent all the time. You’ve gotta have enough relationship to say you want a candidate who’s gonna ma- make a huge difference in your business. You know, trust me to do what I do. But I think you have to have the [00:41:00] relationship to be able to have that kind of advocacy with people. So that, that’s probably my, my main message

That’s a great message, Chris.

Uh, it, it, it… I just reflected on, uh, you know, I’ll tell a story here. I went, I was brought into the Home Depot. This is where I kinda cut my teeth, um, to, to help build out… It was a contract role, too. It was, it was, it was right after 9/11, there was a little mini recession. I was, uh, asked to come in, and they were building out this supply chain team and, and, uh, I sat with the recruiting department.

We were, like, on the bottom floor in the corner of this, you know, big, you know, mega complex, uh, over in, uh, Vinings, outside of Atlanta, uh, where, uh, where Home Depot’s headquartered. And yeah, I did, I did that project and, and it was a success. They asked me to stay on and, and help with a lot of other, uh, needs.

And I, I remember I was in the elevator one time, and, uh, the, uh, you know, the person that ran their [00:42:00] supply chain, back then it was called Global Logistics, a guy named Wayne Gibson, um, he reported to the CEO, uh, there at Home Depot. They were Fortune 13 back then. And, uh, I just remember he said, he said, “Hey, when are, when are you gonna move up here?

Um, I want you to sit with the business, um, and, and kind of be more of that business partner.” I’m like, “Yeah, I guess I need to go check with, with, uh, the, my TA leader and make sure that’s okay.” We’re all sitting centralized, again, bottom floor corner of the, of this complex. And, uh, and I, I remember moving up there, and they had me sit in with, uh, you know, they…

the leadership team and supply chain would meet once a week, and they’d, uh, have me come in, they’d have the finance person come in, the HR business partner as well. And I just… You know, that’s when the light bulb went off. Like, you know, to, to be successful at this, uh, it goes back to your earlier point, is be a great business partner.

Be proactive, try to be involved, understand their strategy, you know, understand problems they’re trying [00:43:00] to solve for. Um, by that executive integrating me into his team, I sat on that logistics and supply… Well, there were two floors. I sat on, uh, the floors and beside of my HR and finance, you know, the supporting cast members to the organization.

And, and, um, and from that moment forward, I wasn’t always asked to sit with the business unit. That was a pretty unique opportunity, but, um, it still gave me that, uh, you know, kind of that mindset, um, going forward as I continued to work for other companies, um, Coca-Cola, uh, Kimberly-Clark, et cetera, you know, to still take that type of an approach, be proactive as it relates to, to getting in and, and, and building relationships with the business and understanding their priorities and, and things like that.

So I just wanted to call that out. That’s… You, you know, you said that. That was the, that was the big one, and I 100% agree.

Mike, let’s kick it over to you. Uh, let’s… How can practitioners leverage, you know, the [00:44:00] information we’ve shared in the series for their benefit?

Mike Ogle: Well, all these things that we’ve talked about previously and in this particular episode as well of trying to have a great understanding of what are you really looking for and what are all these different characteristics that you wanna prioritize.

In the same way, then if you’re a candidate for a position, you need– you really need to be able to think about those same kinds of, of considerations. Do you really know what they are? Can you articulate them? So if employers and recruiters and that whole world of people, whether it’s HR, whether it’s some, you know, professionals that you plan to work with or would like to work with, if they can’t understand the scale and complexity of your experience, then you’re gonna miss opportunities.

So you need to prioritize those as well. Do you really understand the different things that you’ve done and have you [00:45:00] quantified the kinds of things that are part of your background? You know, what ki- size of teams have you been with? What kinds of facilities have you been in? You know, what is your, what is your network like?

Uh, because that’s actually another factor that people don’t tend to think about all that often is, you know, can somebody put out there, “Well, how big is your network and how well have you maintained them?” And, and you can utilize this as a, as a real source of strength. You know, the, the revenues, uh, or, or complexity and size of the supply chain, you know, the budget that you’re responsible for, what kind of throughput and volume and sites.

It, it’s really all these things that we’ve talked about that you’re, on the other side, somebody is looking for. Do you have ready, not just bullet lists, but stories really behind it so that you can talk about how you’ve dealt with automation and the kinds of environments you’ve worked in, transformational [00:46:00] experiences that you’ve been part of?

Can you really provide a business outcome that was clear of a project that you worked on? So, you know, you can’t just assume that your title ends up explaining what you do and what you want to do, ’cause both of those are going to be important. It’s not just, hey, how do you have somebody find you? But how do you have somebody find you and understanding that you’re ready for a next step, for instance, and why?

And you can explain that well. Can you give a contact– context to have somebody understand your scope? You know, can you explain what you personally owned rather than just saying, “Hey, I was part of this, this particular, uh, project that was being worked on by the, by the company”? Can you show some progression of how you’ve learned and have you been able to take on increasing roles and complexity, not just that you went up in title?[00:47:00]

But can you make those transformations clear? Can you quantify those results? You know, how can you be able to tell somebody, for instance, that you’ve got skills that are transferable to other things so that when a search is done, it, it doesn’t just show where you were in a particular industry? And I would say one of the things that, that kinda to me is, is critical, you know, and you need to make sure what you want to do and what you want to accomplish is absolutely clear.

So when we think about kind of a closing question here, you know, what’s the one thing that supply chain professionals could do today to make the scale and complexity of their experience easier for employers to find and understand? And think about with the increasing role of AI, have you thought about the kinds of things that AI might be looking for so that you even make that first cut[00:48:00]

Yeah, Mike, that’s a, a, that’s a really good question. Um, what can I do as a supply chain practitioner or a leader or an executive to really cut through, you know, maybe some of these assumptions and ambiguity to help the employers or recruiters make it really easy to understand? I think AI is a good application for that, you know.

Um, but you also need to really, critical thinking-wise, put, put yourself in the shoes of an employer, assume they don’t know everything, um, and, and make it really easy, uh, layman’s terms. I mean, you don’t, you know, spell it out in layman’s terms, but I think, you know, make sure from a keyword perspective, knowing recruiters, employers are searching against, you know, LinkedIn or their resume database or they’re filtering applications, you know, they are gonna be filtering by what are those common…

What’s the co- common denominator, you know, for this particular skill [00:49:00] or system or tool and so forth. So you’ve got to just put your mind into, you know, um, uh, the mind of, of a recruiter or HR person and, and kind of think about a FAQ. What are, what are the things they’re gonna wanna know? I mean, if you’re at a manufacturing site, um, you probably…

You know, you don’t need to spell out every little nook and cranny y- when it comes to the physical attributes, but, you know, you, you should, you should understand the basics of, of what you should communicate. You could apply that into all of the different functions. I mean, I could go through each one. We don’t have time to do that.

But, you know, procurement, like what are… Are you on the direct side? Are you working with raw materials, components, you know, things like that? Or are you on the indirect side where it’s more working with service providers, um, across different categories like IT or HR or, you know, finance or professional services, labor, et cetera, right?

Uh, what is the spend? You know, what is the complexity? You know, make sure you spell [00:50:00] that out. Those are some examples. I’m sure you guys have some too.

Chris Gaffney: Yeah, I mean, I, I actually would throw in a perspective to some of the younger folks who might be listening to this and, you know, how am I gonna position myself well?

And, and it’s interesting, I was talking to my wife about leadership, and my wife has done a lot of leadership. And it was like, how do you come to leadership? And our own consensus on that is you mostly come to it through accountability. Somewhere earlier in your days when something needed to be done, you stepped up and you just said…

You know, that’s the classic definition we had at Coke. If it’s to be, it’s up to me. So, you know, for those folks who are like, you know, “I aspire to that job,” it, it’s that early history of stepping up and saying, “I’ll, I’ll take the lead on that,” selflessly or whatever. You know, later on in life, those skills are gonna be the ones that differentiate you, and they start you having the story that you can tell to back up what’s on your [00:51:00] resume.

You’ve got the fodder that basically is, “I really pack the gear.” So I think that’s important, and that stating… If you could stay that way all the way through your career. I had a boss who was like, “I want someone who’s continually progressing, even with small steps. I want someone who demonstrates success.”

And I think you get a lot of that by being accountable and by always stepping up when there’s something else to do. And in the context of the world that we live in today and what we’ve been talking about, I also think demonstrating agility is important. You’re, you’re… You know, you want to be that candidate who, you know, when they say, “This person doesn’t have everything,” you want the recruiter to say, “But look, they’ve worked in these different environments and different companies, and they’ve moved around their own company, and they have a record of success, which means they are able to transfer what they had and fill in what they didn’t and continue to be successful.”

And I think, to me as a candidate, if you can tell those stories, [00:52:00] you’re, you’re gonna be competitive. You know? You, you… Back to our kickball analogy. You’re gonna get picked pretty early on the team. So those are just some thoughts that, that, that I have. And like I say, back to the no AI thing. I don’t need an AI resume, ’cause when I talk to you, you’re not gonna be able to tell the story that matches what’s on the page.

I’d rather you go do the work and have a great story on the page, but you can tell it because you lived it, you know?

Yeah. Uh, we’re hearing a lot of complaints from clients and employers about, uh, their applications coming into their inbox, uh, where, hmm, you know, these all– a lot of people seem to be qualified.

They have a lot of the keyword. That’s because now job seekers have those AI tools, and they’re able to quickly customize their resumes around every single job application. And, uh, that’s compounding the complexity, uh, that we’re all dealing with, um, to try to identify who are, are, are these best candidates that are out there that best fit.[00:53:00]

Mike Ogle: Yeah. When I end up having, uh, conversations with students and look at their resumes or they want a recommendation or they wanna talk about, you know, getting jobs in, in supply chain, and sometimes when I look at, at resumes and there’s this list of 12 clubs that they were part of, and, you know, there’s so many things that end up just saying, “Hey, I was part of this.”

What part? You know, what, what, what did you do as part of that work to be able to demonstrate, as, you know, Chris was saying, that, that leadership aspect of it. You know, how did you step up? What did you have responsibility for? Uh, what were some of the complexities that you ran into? Because early on, employers are looking for the ability to flex, to be able to adjust to uncertainty and things like that.

And if a, if a student can really demonstrate that early on, they’ve got a big leg up [00:54:00] if, if they can just tell the story as opposed to just putting down a bunch of bullet items. Yeah.

Well, we’ll close this out real quick. I’m just gonna run through, um, you know, the core things that, uh, that we’ve talked about as, as we’ll close this out. So, uh, we know supply chain hiring is, is, is very, uh, difficult and challenging. We’ve kind of covered the reasons why. It’s, it’s just a complex field with a, a whole lot of ambiguity.

We know that titles, uh, rarely tell the whole story. Job descriptions rarely tell the whole story. Even, even like looking into the industry, it’s not gonna give you everything that you, you need or hope for, right? Um, the best hiring process starts with understanding the broader business, you know, not just in supply chain, but how it connects across all the other functions, I would argue externally to customers and the different channels to, you know, to the supply base.

Um, I, I like to [00:55:00] understand, uh, from a high level all of those different components. You know, then– and then look back like where, you know, quickly look back in history, you know, where, how, where did we start? How did we get to where we’re at today? And then what do we need to do, um, going forward, right? I mean, that’s what we’re trying to solve for going forward.

Um, force rank those objectives, deliverables, and then determine which of those capabilities matter the most while understanding if you can’t get that laundry list of things that you are hoping to find, that preferred skill set, you know, what are those trade-offs? Um, go to the market with an open mind.

Um, don’t be stubborn and insistent that they’ve got to have A to Z. Um, you’re just gonna drag out that, that search and, and you might find it coming up on a birthday at some point in time. I’ve seen those before. Um, if the market tells you your, your original candidate profile or, or original sourcing strategy, uh, and/or your compensation that you had in mind is, is not generating the right candidates, you [00:56:00] need to, to listen.

You need to take the time to, to reflect. Um, look at the data from the candidates that you have, uh, interviewed and talked with, and, and then you can fine-tune your strategy going forward Um, sometimes that best candidate may not come from a certain list of companies, your own industry, or even the background that you originally envisioned.

Goes back to having an, an open mind versus a closed mind and, and, and kind of listen to your, your, your recruiting or talent acquisition partner too. They’re the ones that are out there day in, day out talking to people. Um, uh, and, and you can learn a lot from those insights, especially if you’re a collaborative, uh, partner on that search from start to finish.

Uh, sometimes getting that right person may cost a little extra, and you’re gonna have to evaluate, you know, is, is this juice worth the squeeze, you know? Um, it, it… Sometimes you, we, we might be on a search for six months, and it’s a tight profile, and we find [00:57:00] that right candidate. They need an additional $5,000 above the range, and nothing more frustrating than someone that says, “I, I…”

Sorry, especially a large corporation, like, “We can’t do that.” Um, or they don’t have any creative way to do it, and then we’re back to, to square one. Um, what’s the cost of keeping that role open further? Um, HR, talent acquisition, you know, those that recruit in this space, um, can then focus on finding the right combination of capabilities rather than finding exact match, you know, titles and keywords.

Um, candidates, you need to have, uh, put more effort into defining, you know, the size, scope, complexity, the scale, um, and then quantifying the results of your, of your accomplishments. Make it really easy to understand, um, not only in the resume, but, you know, LinkedIn is where, where many folks, uh, look for talent, most employers.

So don’t just put your [00:58:00] titles up there. I could… I mean, we’ve talked about this. We’ve got past episodes and tons of content on the, on the website where we talk about how to optimize your LinkedIn profile. But, you know, go back through that lens of, of, uh, you know, just assume that the folks that are receiving your application assume they are not supply chain experts.

Make it super easy for them to understand what you’ve done, how you did it, what were the accomplishments, you know, while making sure you have those, those critical keywords that most employers are searching for. Um, and just, you know, leverage AI appropriately. Don’t, don’t have it create everything for you.

Don’t overdo it. You know, you don’t, you don’t want AI to write your resume from scratch. Ideally, you write the draft and then have AI polish it and, you know, and, and give it, uh, the right prompts. “Hey, is this, you know, is this something that a non-supply chain, uh, person, example HR or, or a recruiter could understand?”

If you overload it with jargon acronyms, [00:59:00] um, it, it might get lost, um, in the crowd. So those are some of the pieces of advice I have. Mike, Chris, anything else you want to add?

Chris Gaffney: No, I mean, I, I think you get what you pay for, right? Um, and that’s where I, I historically, you know… If, if I remember my own situations when I was building teams, and it was always like, be patient, do the legwork, get the right person.

Um, and if you don’t do that, you know, you’re back at the drawing board and where you’ve hired somebody who does a lot of damage in your organization. So I, I think it’s so precious in terms of bringing talent into your organization, and th- this just goes to the same whether you’re promoting internally or not.

Doing that shortcut gets you nothing in this space, right? It– And so give it the focus, give it the time if it really matters to you. And this, you know, this goes back to a topic we discuss is how [01:00:00] important is talent in your organization, and it all shows by the level of focus that you put against it.

Mike Ogle: And I’d say one other thought from me is something that I end up sharing in my classes when we talk about jobs and responsibilities and trying to progress through organizations, uh, particularly in the organization, uh, the operations management class that I teach.

And that’s really thinking about early on in a, in a career of not focusing so much on the titles and the compensation as far as, you know, base pay, uh, but really being able to look at the kinds of things that are long-term career enhancing, that are like investments. You know, “Hey, can you spend a little bit more money to be able to send me to some different meetings and, and conferences, and can you train me and get me certain certifications or whatever along the way?”

Those are things that are probably more palatable within an [01:01:00] organization as opposed to just flat outright paying somebody more money, and they don’t compare well to others across the organization.

Need help hiring Supply Chain Leaders?

Connect with our recruiting team here at SCM Talent Group to elevate your team’s potential and secure the supply chain leadership talent your organization needs for future success!

Check Out Other Podcast Episodes:

Podcast: Launching Off the Career Springboard – with Brett Frankenberg, Coca-Cola Supply Chain Executive

June 20, 2022|

Supply Chain Careers podcast hosts, Rodney Apple and Chris Gaffney dive into conversation with Supply Chain Executive, Brett Frankenberg. Brett shares how he got started in supply chain through his curiosity about how things work in the physical operation side, but eventually was given an opportunity to get involved in higher-level enterprise systems.

Go to Top